Big Network Agency vs. Small Independent Agency: Where Should You Build Your Advertising Career?
- jmpaulik
- Nov 21, 2022
- 3 min read
Updated: Aug 5

Spoiler alert: There’s no one-size-fits-all answer.But if you’re serious about building a kickass career in advertising account management, this is a choice you can’t afford to sleepwalk through.
Because where you start — or where you pivot next — will shape not just your resume, but your skills, your sanity, your network, and your day-to-day experience for years to come.
So let’s break it down. No fluff. No BS. Just what you need to know.
The Big Network Agency: Welcome to the Machine
Think: WPP, Publicis, Omnicom, IPG — the big dogs with even bigger client rosters.
The Good Stuff:
Big brands, big budgets: You’ll get to name-drop clients your parents have actually heard of. Managing a multimillion-dollar account looks real good on your CV.
Structured training: Many big agencies actually invest in training. You’ll get frameworks, processes, performance reviews — and, if you’re lucky, a mentor who knows their sh*t.
Networking on steroids: Thousands of colleagues = thousands of future contacts when you inevitably jump ship in a few years.
The Not-So-Good Stuff:
You’re a cog, not a craftsman: Roles are super siloed. You may own client status reports but never touch strategy. Worse, decision-making can feel like steering the Titanic with a canoe paddle.
Office politics: Get ready for passive-aggressive emails, endless meetings about meetings, and promotions that seem based more on who you know than what you’ve done.
Burnout is real: You are replaceable. And you’ll feel it.
In short: If you want a well-known name on your resume, crave structure, and don't mind playing the long game (and the occasional political chess match), a big network agency might be your move.
The Small Independent Agency: Pirates, Not the Navy
Think: Boutique shops, creative independents, agencies that call themselves "non-traditional" and actually mean it.
The Good Stuff:
Wear 10 hats: You’ll touch everything — strategy, creative, media, production. Scary? Sure. But you’ll build full-stack skills fast.
Real ownership: Smaller teams mean your voice matters. Clients will know your name. Your ideas might actually, y’know, happen.
Culture (usually) doesn’t suck: Less corporate BS. More beers-after-work, dogs-in-the-office vibes.
The Not-So-Good Stuff:
Training is DIY: No corporate learning portal here. You’ll need to hustle hard for your own development.
Budgets are tighter: Don’t expect Super Bowl ads. Expect "Can we make this $5k look like $50k?" problems.
Instability is baked in: One lost client can trigger layoffs. Leadership drama can turn toxic, fast.
In short: If you want hands-on experience, faster career acceleration, and don't mind a bit of chaos, an indie shop could be a launchpad to greatness.
So, Which One’s Best for You?
Here's the brutal truth: it depends on what kind of career (and life) you want.
Ask yourself:
Do I want prestige or practicality right now? (Big agency = prestige. Small agency = skills.)
Am I self-motivated or do I need structure?
Can I handle uncertainty without freaking out?
What energizes me more: working on a global campaign or building something scrappy from scratch?
Also: Think about your next-next job.Where do you want to be in 5 years? Different paths open different doors.
Choose Your Adventure (Wisely)
Both paths can lead to satisfying careers in account management — but they’ll shape you differently.
A big agency will train you in systems, scale, and surviving complexity.
A small agency will train you in adaptability, creativity, and doing more with less.
Neither is "better."Only better for you, right now.
Just make sure whichever you pick, you go all in. Show up hungry. Be the person who gets sh*t done. Make it impossible for your bosses (and your clients) to forget your name.
That's how you build a career — no matter where you start.
Comments